Mince Pie Ratings

A team of industry leading experts (although the industry is not in anyway related to food production or critiquing) have been reviewing a range of mince pies and this website is the result of those, in no way scientific or possibly even accurate, reviews.


Pie Rating
ASDA Iced Mince Pies 6.71
ASDA Mince Pies 6.33
Mr Kipling Deep Filled Mince Pies 6.29
Holly Lane Deep Mince Pie (Aldi) 5.80
Tesco Mince Pie "Butter enriched pastry" 5.56
Sainsbury’s Deep Filled Mince Pies 4.68
First bakery mine pies going up for rating today @greggs_official
CO-OP irresistible luxury mince pies have been added, alongside the CO-OP free from pies
Ooh a fancy Brandy butter pie, quite a high PPP (price per pie) though!
It’s a hard job, but we’re dedicated to finding the answer #bestmincepie2017
Time to start rating all these pies!