Mince Pie Ratings

A team of industry leading experts (although the industry is not in anyway related to food production or critiquing) have been reviewing a range of mince pies and this website is the result of those, in no way scientific or possibly even accurate, reviews.


Pie Rating
Lidl - Favorina 6.93
Iceland standard 5.35
CO-OP bakery shortcrust 5.16
CO-OP Deep filled 4.88
Aldi Speciality - Cognac 4.42
Tesco's Finest 4.42
M&S All Butter Mince pies 4.40
ASDA extra special All Butter 4.02
Greggs Sweet Mince Pies 4.02
Sainsbury's Deep Filled 3.70
Asda Standard 3.58
Aldi Speciality - Salted Caramel 3.33
CO-OP Irresistible Luxury Mince Pies 2.51
Lidl - Deluxe Brandy Butter Mince Pies 2.43
Waitrose All butter 1.24
Tesco's Free from (Gluten free) 0.43